Randomised double blind placebo controlled trial of inhaled fluticasone propionate in infants with chronic lung disease
- Correspondence to:
Dr N J Shaw, Neonatal Unit, Liverpool Women's Hospital, Liverpool L8 7SS, UK;
- Accepted 19 February 2002
In a double blind randomised controlled trial, 30 infants with chronic lung disease received fluticasone propionate or placebo for one year. There were no significant differences between treatment groups in the incidence of any day or night time symptoms or any other outcome measures.
Chronic lung disease of prematurity (CLD) is associated with significant respiratory morbidity in the early years of life.1,2 Systemic corticosteroids reduce the duration of respiratory support in infants at risk of developing CLD.3 Inhaled corticosteroids reduce symptoms in wheezing infants.4 No randomised controlled studies have assessed the efficacy of inhaled corticosteroids as prophylactic therapy in CLD. We report the results of a randomised double blind placebo controlled trial of inhaled fluticasone propionate in infants with CLD, which aimed to determine whether the regular use of an inhaled corticosteroid reduces respiratory morbidity.
Infants studied required supplementary oxygen at 36 postmenstrual weeks. They were excluded if they were ventilated or receiving systemic corticosteroids at this time. Local research ethics approval was granted and written informed parental consent obtained. Infants were randomised to receive 250 μg twice daily of inhaled fluticasone propionate or placebo via metered dose inhaler (with spacer and face mask) for a one year study period. Treatment allocation was double blinded. Primary outcome was the incidence of reported symptom free days. Secondary outcomes included symptom frequency (assessed using a symptom diary), growth parameters, and hospital admissions. It was estimated that placebo treated infants may experience symptoms on 50% of days. Sample size calculation, looking for a 20% reduction in symptom frequency in fluticasone treated infants (80% power, 95% confidence) revealed that 63 infants were required in each treatment arm. After two years recruitment, it became evident that the original sample size would not be achieved in a reasonable time. A decision was taken to stop the trial but to report available data for use in designing future studies or systematic reviews.
Thirty infants were randomised to the study; 15 received fluticasone (table 1). Two infants in the fluticasone treated group and three in the placebo arm withdrew from the trial without completing diaries. Three infants had no symptom diaries complete despite continuing treatment, one from the fluticasone arm and two from the placebo arm of the trial.
There were no significant differences between treatment groups in the incidence of any day or night time symptoms (table 2). The median (interquartile range) duration of continuous oxygen therapy was 181 days (133–301) for fluticasone and 119 days (56–280) for placebo treated infants (p = 0.4), while the median duration of inhaler usage was 350 days (113–373) and 242 days (97–301) respectively (p = 0.4). There was no significant difference between treatment groups with respect to weight gain expressed as Z score or increase in hospital admissions for respiratory illness, number of courses of oral corticosteroids, or the use of bronchodilator therapy during the study period.
Fluticasone is a potent inhaled corticosteroid5 and the lack of a major clinical effect might be a result of poor treatment adherence, an insensitive outcome measure, or a type II error. Double blinding of participants optimised the chance of detecting a significant treatment effect. Stratification by centre compensated for potential variation in management regimes. Efficacy of an inhaled prophylactic therapy depends on adequate and regular administration. Parents were trained in the inhaler technique and regularly monitored. Being a pragmatic trial, no objective measure of treatment adherence (for example, weighing of canisters) was adopted. Use of symptom diaries, though easy to complete and regularly supervised, relies on parental motivation and interpretation of symptoms. The eight infants either withdrawing or not completing symptom diaries were excluded from analyses. No data were available for the primary outcome measure and therefore they could not be included in an intention to treat analysis.
This study provides useful data regarding respiratory symptomatology in placebo treated infants with CLD. Approximately 19% of infants with CLD treated with placebo had short episodes of cough or wheeze during the day and 20% had similar episodes sufficient to wake them at least once at night. These are substantially lower frequencies than our estimated values for sample size calculation (50%) and indicate that a much larger sample size would be need to detect important differences in symptom frequency in this population.
In conclusion, this is a small, negative outcome study that does not encourage clinicians to start inhaled corticosteroids prophylactically in infants with CLD. A larger clinical trial of treatment in symptomatic children with CLD would be the next appropriate step.
We thank Allen and Hanburys for supplying the inhalers and diaries.